Scholz rebukes Vance, defends Europe’s stance on hate speech and far right

German Chancellor Olaf Scholz speaks during the Munich Security Conference (MSC) in Munich, Germany, February 15, 2025. REUTERS/Wolfgang Rattay

Scholz Rebukes U.S. Vice President Over Criticism of Europe’s Free Speech Laws

Dispute Over Hate Speech and the Far Right

German Chancellor Olaf Scholz delivered a firm response on Saturday to U.S. Vice President JD Vance’s remarks criticizing Europe’s approach to hate speech and far-right politics. Speaking at the Munich Security Conference, Scholz rejected Vance’s comments, asserting that it was inappropriate for foreign officials to dictate Germany and Europe’s political stance.

• Vance, in his speech on Friday, accused European leaders of censoring free speech and denounced Germany’s political isolation of the far-right Alternative for Germany (AfD).
• Scholz countered, stating that Germany has legitimate reasons for maintaining a firewall against the AfD, which has been politically ostracized due to historical sensitivities related to Germany’s Nazi past.

“Never again fascism, never again racism, never again aggressive war. That is why an overwhelming majority in our country opposes anyone who glorifies or justifies criminal National Socialism,” Scholz said.

The AfD, which is currently polling at around 20% ahead of Germany’s February 23 national election, remains politically marginalized due to concerns about ultranationalism.

European Officials Defend Hate Speech Regulations

Other European leaders also rejected Vance’s remarks, emphasizing that Europe’s approach to hate speech and democracy is rooted in historical awareness.

• Scholz defended Germany’s strict regulations, arguing that modern democracies must protect themselves from radical anti-democratic forces.
• French Foreign Minister Jean-Noel Barrot responded on social media, stating:“No one is required to adopt our model, but no one can impose theirs on us. Freedom of speech is guaranteed in Europe.”

Vance’s endorsement of the AfD, including a meeting with the party’s leader, was viewed in Berlin as unwelcome election interference.

Lack of Focus on Ukraine and Russia

The Munich Security Conference was expected to focus heavily on diplomatic efforts to end the Ukraine-Russia war, particularly in light of President Donald Trump’s recent call with Russian President Vladimir Putin. However, Vance largely avoided the topic, instead focusing on immigration and free speech issues in Europe.

• Vance stated that his primary concerns regarding Europe were not Russia or China, but rather what he described as a decline in fundamental freedoms and uncontrolled immigration.
• His remarks were met with stunned silence from many conference delegates, and little applause followed his speech.
• When asked whether Vance’s speech contained anything worth serious reflection, Scholz responded with a deadpan retort, drawing laughter and applause from the audience:“You mean all these very relevant discussions about Ukraine and security in Europe?”

The sharp exchanges at the Munich Security Conference highlight the growing transatlantic divide over key political values, particularly regarding hate speech laws and Europe’s handling of far-right movements.