New Jersey’s top Catholic leader, Cardinal Joseph Tobin, is once again under scrutiny for his handling of transparency in abuse investigations. Despite previous promises, his administration has been criticized for withholding information and obstructing state inquiries. Calls for accountability are growing as state officials and advocacy groups demand immediate action and the release of critical reports.
A History of Promises for Transparency
In 2019, Cardinal Joseph Tobin of Newark pledged a “new level of transparency” after publishing a list of clergy accused of sexual abuse. However, critics argue that the Archdiocese of Newark has since failed to provide full disclosure on allegations involving church officials, including those linked to former Cardinal Theodore McCarrick.
Blocking Investigations and Allegations of Cover-Ups
Despite Tobin’s public commitment to transparency, reports suggest that the archdiocese has actively withheld details about abuse cases. Seton Hall University, under the jurisdiction of the archdiocese, has faced backlash for promoting Joseph Reilly to university president despite his past failure to report abuse allegations. Additionally, the Camden diocese—likely with Tobin’s approval—successfully blocked a state-led investigation into clergy abuse through legal action.
State Officials Demand Action
New Jersey lawmakers, including State Senators Joseph Vitale and Andrew Zwicker, have urged the archdiocese to release key findings from a 2019 investigation into Seton Hall’s abuse cases. They argue that Tobin’s recent hiring of a law firm for an internal review is a delaying tactic rather than a genuine effort for transparency.
Survivors and Advocacy Groups Speak Out
Victims’ advocacy groups, such as the Survivors Network of those Abused by Priests (SNAP), have criticized Tobin for failing to take decisive action. They argue that his office could have intervened to ensure full cooperation with the state’s ongoing investigations.
Legal Battles and Church Resistance
In a secret court hearing in May 2023, the Camden diocese successfully petitioned a judge to halt parts of the state’s clergy abuse investigation. This decision is now being challenged in the New Jersey Supreme Court, while the attorney general’s office insists on continuing its work to bring justice to victims.
What Comes Next?
With growing pressure from state lawmakers and advocacy groups, Tobin and the Archdiocese of Newark face mounting challenges. The outcome of the Supreme Court case and the release of Seton Hall’s investigation findings could determine whether the church upholds its commitment to transparency or continues to face accusations of cover-ups.
COMMENTS