HomeSenate News

California Democratic Senate Debate: Winners, Losers, and Surprises

Candidates Adam Schiff, Katie Porter and Steve Garvey participate in the first California Senate debate at Bovard Auditorium at the University of Southern California in Los Angeles on Jan. 22. | Jenna Schoenefeld for POLITICO


Californians tuned in for a 90-minute debate among candidates aspiring to succeed the late Sen. Dianne Feinstein. The spotlight was on whether Republican candidate Steve Garvey would disclose his vote for Donald Trump, with Democrats Katie Porter, Barbara Lee, and Adam Schiff taking center stage.

Winners of the Night: Katie Porter’s Debate Prowess

Despite relentless attacks on her opposition to congressional earmark spending and her nuanced stance on Israel, Porter showcased exceptional debate skills. Blaming corporations for Washington’s issues and challenging Schiff’s financial ties, Porter positioned herself strongly for the November runoff.

Garvey’s Struggles: GOP Candidate’s Tough Night

Republican Steve Garvey faced sustained attacks, failing to provide clarity on his presidential vote. Vague responses and a lack of specificity on key issues left viewers unconvinced. Garvey’s performance fell short of expectations, and even references to Ronald Reagan couldn’t salvage his night.

Surprises and Lack of Grasp: Garvey’s Murky Approach

The most surprising aspect was Garvey’s lack of grasp on crucial issues. His struggles to articulate clear answers and reliance on vague statements raised concerns about his suitability for the powerful office. Despite attempts to pivot with references to compassion and sovereignty, Garvey failed to meet expectations.

Adam Schiff: Meeting Expectations and Core Messages

Adam Schiff, a leader in the race, performed as expected. Defending democracy, standing against Trumpism, and emphasizing his record of getting things done, Schiff presented himself as a candidate ready to lead in significant battles for California.

Subscribe to our newsletter

COMMENTS